Thesis Thursday: Is the average stock taking the lead?
The equal-weight S&P closed at a one-year high Wednesday and is down only about 2.0% today while the Nasdaq proxy falls about 4.5%. Friday's jobs report and Tuesday's inflation data decide whether that is a real handoff or just a softer landing.
In short
- The average stock catching up is heating again: the equal-weight S&P is down about 2.0% today against about 4.5% for the Nasdaq proxy, a day after its highest close in a year.
- Bull: it is up about 5.3% since Sep 30 while the Nasdaq proxy is down about 10.7%. Bear: small caps are down about 2.9% today, so the rest of the market is falling too, just less.
- Friday's 8:30 AM ET jobs report, forecast at 55,000, then Tuesday's inflation report test whether the lead holds once the market bounces.
What would settle it
Three dates. Friday at 8:30 AM ET brings the October jobs report, with payrolls forecast at 55,000 after 29,000 and unemployment at 4.2%. A steady number helps the banks, factories and retailers that fill the equal-weight index, while a weak one tests whether small caps can hold. Tuesday, Nov 10 at 8:30 AM ET brings October consumer prices, after core prices rose 0.3% in September. Then Nvidia reports after the close on Nov 17, with options pricing a move of about 9.6%. The story ends if big tech retakes the lead for weeks while equal weight lags. Until then, the equal-weight S&P beating the S&P proxy on jobs day and through the inflation report keeps it alive.
Desk read
The evidence leans bull on the relative story, with moderate confidence. Five weeks of the equal-weight index beating the big-cap ones, a one-year high on Wednesday, and fear that sits in Nasdaq options rather than small-cap ones all point to a real broadening. The caution is that today the whole market is falling and small caps are falling with it, so the average stock is winning a relative race in a losing market. If it keeps its lead when the S&P proxy bounces, that is a handoff. If it only wins on down days, it is a softer landing. This is a read of the evidence, not a trade call.
Get this in your inbox.
The Desk's feature every day, plus the market mood. Free. Unsubscribe anytime. Privacy