Thesis Thursday: Is AI spending getting harder to pay for?
Chipmakers rallied about 7% this week while the biggest spenders, Alphabet and Meta, sold off on their own reports. Amazon tonight and Nvidia on Nov 18 decide whether the market keeps paying for the buildout.
In short
- The AI spending boom is back after last week's scare: the chip ETF is up about 7.2% this week, but the companies paying for it are falling, with Alphabet off about 11.7% today.
- Bull: Alphabet kept its $195 billion to $205 billion spending range and says 2027 rises significantly. Bear: the market is punishing the spenders, and posts say Microsoft and Alphabet both spent less than expected last quarter.
- Amazon reports after the close today with an implied move of about 6.8%, then AMD on Nov 3 and Nvidia on Nov 18.
What would settle it
Four reports in the next three weeks. Amazon reports after the close today with an implied move of about 6.8%, and its spending plan for next year is the first test. Apple follows on Nov 2 (implied about 3.4%), AMD on Nov 3 (about 7.2%) and Nvidia on Nov 18 (about 7.3%). On the tape, the story's own end condition is chip stocks falling on good reports. If the chip ETF slides back toward its Oct 22 close near 523 after strong numbers, the bear case wins. A close back above its Oct 5 level near 634 would say last week's scare is fully over.
Desk read
The evidence leans bull, with moderate confidence. The spending plans held, the biggest spenders are borrowing to keep them, and the suppliers rallied hardest this week. What changed is who pays: the market is charging the spenders, not the chipmakers, for the bill. That split, with Meta and Alphabet down while AMD and Lam Research rise, is the thing to watch. If Amazon lifts its spending tonight and chips rise with it, the split widens in the bulls' favor. If chips fall on good news from Amazon and AMD, the story is cooling for real. This is a read of the evidence, not a trade call.
Get this in your inbox.
The Desk's feature every day, plus the market mood. Free. Unsubscribe anytime. Privacy